Wednesday, July 30, 2025
Sunday, December 29, 2024
The H-1B Program
I’m curious about all of the rhetoric regarding H-1B visas for specialty skills that are not demonstrably available through available US Citizens.
When I was a senior manager at a Bay Area medical device company, I had several H-1B’s reporting to me when I assumed the role. They were mostly from India but also from México, and were engineers all.
During my tenure, I had three openings I attempted to fill with US Citizen talent. I hired US Citizens from Silicon Valley and had to terminate all three during the probationary period for being largely ineffective. There were no candidates that met the minimum requirements AND did not have prior performance or behavioral red flags.
The team I inherited was strong and effective.
This was near the end of a five year period of remediation, and prior to my arrival the recruitment process was led by a turn-around team who knew how to, you know, recruit.
Recruitment is not an instantaneous process of looking for a “clot for a slot” as Dr. Laurence J. Peter (Peter Principle fame) would coin the phrase.
Recruiting growable, loyal, passionate talent takes time, typically months, including scouring outplacement sessions for Armed Services officers, warrant officers, and technical enlistees, and having a network in place and pre-established contacts with high-performers in the market space who may suddenly become available or otherwise entertain evolving their career.
This does not happen without planning led by senior leadership.
Regrettably, HR departments don’t work that way.
They are driven by finance and open requisitions that if not filled in 90 or 120 days, are rescinded by management to stay true to the tyranny of the budget and/or EBIDTA short term bogies, and not the long term.
When a prospective “highly desirable” candidate does became available, there is usually a hiring freeze in effect to cover an operational or programmatic shortfall, or no open position to allow for such a hire. The approval process for a new role takes weeks to months to push through the hiring wickets and checkbox controls to get an answer, and always exceeds the window opening that these sudden candidates have to act upon.
Effectively managing this process takes management focus (and is aided by metrics).
Well run companies budget for and hire candidates on-the-spot, and find roles for them knowing the organization must constantly evolve to stay relevant, and scour the market to identify and be at the ready for future acquisitions.
Poorly run companies do not hire sudden employees, nor develop recruiting networks. Most companies are barely minimally functional with LinkedIn, and are not proficient in my opinion.
I chuckle at the overseas “outsourced” recruitment copy / paste operations that pester LinkedIn members with “opportunities”.
"Dear [LinkedIn member name], I note from your résumé you are a warm body with a heartbeat, a LinkedIn account, and your background is highly impressive. Please do the needful and apply for this junior deputy assistant specialist third class role at a undisclosed company way across the country from your location. No relocation compensation. Six month term. W2’s only.”
In my opinion 95-98% of companies are fairly poorly run from a recruitment standpoint.
Southwest Airlines used to have a process (I do not know if it is still in place) to deliberately manage staffing to place in job openings internal employees two out of three times, and hire outside one out of three times. This was (at that time) a key business metric.
You don’t do this kind of staffing unless you have a constant attention to effective cross-training, regular staff rotation and rigorous evaluation as to how the rotated employees have assimilated their required competencies in their new roles, and whether they demonstrate an ability to stretch to a higher role.
The only way this works is if you have an effective lean internal training system tailored to each role, and (I detest using this word) ‘mentoring' from key employees.
Allied-Signal and General Electric had / have the four (or nine) block system of assessing employees and managing under performers out of the organization and identifying high performers, but generally instead of a core tenant to a manager’s function, this activity devolves over time to a once a year check-box activity, and the output is placed in a three (or two) ring binder where it gathers dust until next year.
No further work stems from the four block to work on improving the company systems and processes, nor helping folks get the help they need to overcome obstacles and grow or feel more loyal to the organization.
Staffing from a pool of high potential (HIPOT) recent college graduates, in-turn rotated through various high profile (and often demanding) roles in an organization (in various capacities, both in and outside of their domain expertise) is another method of developing and identifying internal leadership. The problem with these programs is that after 3-5 years the vast majority of these folks invariably strike out and move on to another employer who values your employees more than you do; program participants having assessed that their larger opportunities lay outside of the current organization.
The process to on-board a H1B through USCIS (for me) was rules based, onerous and pedantic, requiring multiple engagements with the cognizant government agency and a six to nine month time period, and sponsorship. We had to conclusively demonstrate the job market did not have a single person with the requisite skills to staff the role. We had to advertise (canvass) and disclose the applications and CV’s and show why the US Citizen or green card holder applicants did not meet minimum requirements, and could almost automatically expect a challenge from USCIS if you passed on 'minimally viable' domestic applicants.
The H1B’s that worked for me were well above par in performance, but were always worried of losing their jobs, being deported, and always had their recruitment antennae out. So, while diligent and high performers, they were not loyal to the company, despite being loyal to me.
I think the real problem is how companies view “talent”, and treat them.
That is the villain — not the H-1B’s or the program as intended.
The H-1B’s I am familiar with are here (in the US) as a bandaid for a larger problem, and, by-in-large contribute positively corporations.
Additionally, in my opinion, with the decline in primary, secondary and higher education quality, and the obscene cost growth in higher education, it seems to me the talent pool is shrinking, and companies will need to focus more on internal growth and retention and better manage their affairs for the immediate future.
This secular decline has been aided and abetted by the SARS-CoV-2 Wuhan Lab leak (funded by the brightest elites in US government), the resulting COVID-19 pandemic, and especially most world governments’ response to the pandemic and the knock-on effect to children and young adults marching through our educational system.
This all finds us here with a younger population struggling, often working two (or three jobs), concerned that no one cares much about their condition (except every four years), taking basic service roles to bide their time in the hope that manufacturing rebounds in the US (and with each manufacturing job the addition of two to three support and untold supply chain jobs).
It will take more than two years to rebuild our collective hollowed-out manufacturing base; I foresee a decade of necessary change, which must start with leadership and a change in corporate culture. Increasing the cost of commodities
Changing leaders is easy.
Permanently changing culture (and sustaining it) is hard.
Wednesday, June 10, 2020
E Unum Pluribus - The Triumph of Tribalism
[begin sarcasm]
As scribes in attendance feverishly recorded, Pharaoh Phelps I, the leader of NASCAR, was overheard to decree, "Let the Confederate Flag be stricken from every book and tablet. Stricken from every pylon and obelisk of Egypt. Let the name of Robert E. Lee be unheard and unspoken, erased from the memory of man, for all time. So it shall be written, so it shall be done; let the woke times roll.”
[end]
The Mississippi State FlagThe first US Navy JackThe Gadsden “Don’t Tread on Me” Flag (including the Georgia 1st Battalion Flag)The Join Or Die Snake "Benjamin Franklin” FlagThe Battle of Gonzalez FlagThe Thin Blue Line FlagThe Three Percenters FlagThe Ensign of the US Coast GuardThe Seguin “Alamo” FlagThe State Flag of Alabama, Florida, Flag of Scotland, Jersey and any flag in the Commonwealth containing the UK Union Jack, including Hawaii (for the similarity to the Confederate Battle Flag)And possibly The 1824 Alamo Flag (which, was likely never flown over the Alamo) because, cultural appropriation.
Sunday, June 09, 2019
An Old Friend
Locals call this 'Delta Weather', wherein you sail up the San Juan or Sacramento Rivers into the Delta, anchor, and party until you can not party any further, or are arrested; this is not competitive 'sailing weather' on the Bay.
I would explore the roads by swinging a leg over the Beast, and taking various back-roads to find interesting places.
The One place I latched onto early on was to take the McEwen Road exit to Port Costa. The destination is the Warehouse Cafe.
So, I detoured to vector to the Warehouse.
As I sit here, it is an anachronism which has not appreciably changed in the 30 years since first landing. A unique place. One of my all time favorites. It is a place where bikers, yuppie scum, professionals, sports fans, and all manner of humanity; they all get along.
You can sit and watch the ships travel on the river, and the passenger trains pass by, from an establishment that was a warehouse in the 1870's, and now is a Class I dive bar today.
This is one day I'm enjoying immensely. Old Friends are good thing.
Sunday, February 25, 2018
California Progressive Progress
Tuesday, September 19, 2017
Zusammenstöße, Georgia Tech Edition
Saturday, September 16, 2017
Quality Assurance
https://www.ammoland.com/2017/09/sig-sauer-safety-warning-recall-notice-limited-number-rifles/
Friday, September 15, 2017
California AB 785
https://www.gunsamerica.com/blog/ca-legislature-approves-bill-disarm-misdemeanor-hate-crime-offenders/
Freedom of speech, and worshipRight of peaceable assembly and petitionExclusion of establishment of a state religionDue-process and the right to an attorneyProtection from self-incrimination or double jeopardyProhibition of cruel and unusual punishmentProtection from unwarranted search and seizureAnd against having to board government troops in your home (3rd Amendment)
Wednesday, July 05, 2017
The Increase in Entropy in the USA
Victor Davis Hanson <here> points to the continued open nullification of federal immigration law by “sanctuary cities” similar to what the South did with respect to civil rights for blacks in the Jim Crow era. Dennis Prager <here>, Rev. Dr. Susan K. Smith <here>, David Horowitz <here>, all openly speculate.
And now, I read this:
REPORT: Flyers distributed in San Diego calling for the genocide of the “white” race:
http://www.10news.com/news/mysterious-filers-threaten-genocide-of-the-white-race
The Virginian, Robert E. Lee, detested the vitriol and bombast of the South Carolinas leading up to the Civil War, people he called “fire breathers”. He did not want a Civil War. Had Virginia not seceded from the Union, he would have fought for the Union, and today arguably would have been a widely revered general instead of now having communities, goaded by Black Lives Matter, remove all vestiges of the Confederate role in the Civil War from the public, with statues of Robert E. Lee being defaced and removed altogether.
For a people so comparatively well off (compared to the balance of the world’s population) it seems incongruous that we would have such a low threshold to violence. People with nothing more to loose find it very easy to revolt. People of means usually consider the loss of their family, wealth, power, and status before moving to take power away from the government or rage against "the other".
Yet, there is a long history of civil disobedience and riots in the time line of the nation.
Looking at the Wiki of US Riots over time, you get the accurate sense that the 1960’s (53) and 1970’s (30) were a sad time. I remember.
You also get the sense that this decade (2010’s, 32 major riots recorded so far) is on track to at least match both prior decades. The list for 2010’s conveniently omits the 2011 flash mob riot in West Alles at the 2011 Wisconsin State Fair, the 2011 flash mob riot in Des Moines at the Iowa State Fair, and the several flash mob riots in Chicago (3,000 “youths” at the Ford City Mall, 400 “youths” at Navy Pier, 400 “youths” along the Magnificent Mile, and in 2010 the North Avenue Beach closure which outwardly appears to have been suppressed in the press - by the City leadership?). When you reclassify “wilding youths”, not only in Chicago, but Philadelphia, Louisville, and across the large cities as “riots” then you get a feeling that record is in fact larger.
This review does not include the violence against police in Dallas in 2016, but you get a similar flashback to the Texas Tower shooting in Austin Texas in 1966.
I doubt we're headed for a Civil War, but depending on how we deal with what is to come in the waning years of this decade, we could be in for a bumpy ride.
Saturday, February 11, 2017
Fake news is "killing people's minds", says Apple boss Tim Cook
Made-up news reports trying to promote a particular agenda gained huge traction on social media in the US during the election.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2017/02/10/fake-news-killing-peoples-minds-says-apple-boss-tim-cook/
“It has to be ingrained in the schools, it has to be ingrained in the public,” said Mr Cook. “There has to be a massive campaign. We have to think through every demographic.
Well, Comrade Cook.
Sunday, February 05, 2017
I Don't Understand...
On this weekend’s broadcast of “Fox News Sunday,” Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) said President Donald Trump was “splitting” the country apart with what she called “a blizzard of executive orders and memorandums.”http://www.breitbart.com/video/2017/02/05/feinstein-trump-splitting-america-apart-with-blizzard-of-executive-orders/
Thursday, September 08, 2016
How utterly Progressive...
Thursday, August 25, 2016
SECDEF Ash Carter
Monday, July 25, 2016
CNN
http://ijr.com/2016/07/657157-cnn-reporter-spilled-the-beans-about-hillary-during-live-broadcast-right-and-then-the-feed-gets-cut/
Larger implications. Last month, the DNC and security firm CrowdStrike reported that hackers likely working on behalf of two Russian intelligence agencies had broken intoDNC servers and made off with opposition research and email messages. After that report, a hacker calling himself Guccifer 2.0 stepped forward and took responsibility for the hack, saying he had nothing to do with Moscow’s intelligence services. But Guccifer is most likely a fiction created by the GRU, Russian military intelligence, and the FSB, the successor group to the KGB, to mask their role in the hack — and the subsequent attempt to influence the U.S. election.The hackers. One group, FANCY BEAR or APT 28, obtained access in April, while the other, COZY BEAR, or APT 29, first entered the network in the summer of 2015. A good place to start to get a handle on all this is the New York Times’ Adrian Chen’s June 2015 in-depth look at Russian troll and hacker factories.Politics. The Clinton campaign has taken the opportunity to tie the Trump campaign as closely as possible to the Kremlin, with Clinton’s campaign chief, Robby Mook, tellingABC News Sunday that “it’s troubling that some experts are now telling us that this was done by the Russians for the purpose of helping Donald Trump.” The Trump campaign rejected such accusations.Russian connections. Last week, FP’s Dan De Luce and Paul McLeary wrote that Trump has surrounded himself with advisors who have had direct business ties to Moscow, including campaign manager, Paul Manafort, a onetime consultant to the pro-Moscow former president of Ukraine, Viktor Yanukovych. One of his military advisors, retired Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn, was invited to sit at Putin’s table at a December dinner in Moscow sponsored by RT, the government-funded news network, and Carter Page, a former consultant to Russia’s state-owned gas giant, Gazprom, has suggested Washington is to blame for raising tensions with Moscow over Ukraine. Trump’s surrogates also successfully watered down language in the GOP platform to remove calls for arming Ukraine’s forces against pro-Russian separatists.









